Stand Our Ground: The Deanna Stevison Case
Become a Paid Subscriber: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/stand-our-ground/subscribe My cousin was murdered in 2017. The police know who did it, but the case has never gone to court. Why? The perpetrators used Florida’s “Stand Your Ground” defense, a controversial law which was amended the day after the murder occurred to make it an easier defense to claim. What really happened that night? Who pulled the trigger? Was the case fully investigated? Join me as I attempt to find some answers about what happened to Deanna Stevison and why.
S1 E10 · Tue, April 09, 2024
S2 Episode 10: Escambia & Santa Rosa “Stand Your Ground” Cases
In this episode, Kiah discusses several other “Stand Your Ground” cases in Escambia and Santa Rosa counties and how why self-defense was or was not permitted as a defense. She also outlines what to expect as we approach the end of Season 2. Be sure to also check out Kiah’s new podcast “Generation Burnout!”
S2 E9 · Sun, March 31, 2024
S2 Episode 9: Master Plan (& An Apology)
Join Kiah as she continues to investigate what happened to Deanna Stevison on June 8, 2017. In this episode, she discusses new insights from Deanna's correspondence with ex-partner Meghan, who is no longer considered to be connected to the mysterious packages linked to the case. Kiah extends an apology for any prior misconceptions. The episode wraps up with Kiah confronting the actions of an internet figure sending those packages, and establishing firm boundaries for future interactions.
S2 E8 · Mon, March 18, 2024
S2 Episode 8: BAC 0.15
In this episode of "Stand Our Ground," host Kiah delves into the investigation of her cousin Deanna Stevison's murder with the aim to shed light on the evidence, advocating for the case's reexamination, not vigilante justice. The episode explores legal concepts, the effects of alcohol, and the importance of a thorough understanding of Deanna's death, incorporating legal, scientific, and expert perspectives to encourage a critical look at the case.
S2 E1 · Tue, March 12, 2024
S2 Episode 7: Bang Bang Pause Bang
In this episode of "Stand Our Ground," host Kiah Penfield continues her investigation into her cousin Deanna Stevison's murder. She examines evidence like bullet casings and wounds, discussing a Beretta bite on a suspect's hand and the absence of blood on the gun. Kiah speculates on the shooting sequence and the potential for premeditation, considering the roles of other individuals. She invites listeners to share theories that fit the evidence and updates on the "Extinguished" podcast's series on the case.
Bonus · Sat, March 02, 2024
Emergency PSA on Suspicious Packages
This brief bonus episode is my emergency PSA on the suspicious packages that some individuals have been getting in association with Deanna’s case. If you receive a suspicious package, please file a police report and feel free to send me a screenshot of the package. I want to reiterate and emphasize that these actions mean that someone must be feeling very scared and pressured with the attention this case is getting. Please do not stop supporting justice for Deanna. This will not stop me. This will not stop us. This will not stop justice.
S2 E6 · Wed, February 21, 2024
S2 Episode 6: “We Will Never Give Up” (Part Two of Morgan’s Interview)
In this episode of "Stand Our Ground," host Kiah Penfield completes her interview with her guest Morgan, Deanna Stevison's sister. Together, they delve into the investigation of Deanna's murder and the perceived shortcomings of the police work. They discuss the impact on their family and their dissatisfaction with law enforcement's handling of the case. They also touch on the evidence they've uncovered themselves, including suspicious phone activity and untested DNA, and express frustration over the lack of transparency and thoroughness in the investigation. The episode includes a call to action for listeners with information to come forward and help in seeking justice for Deanna.
S1 E5 · Tue, February 13, 2024
S2 Episode 5: What Happened Was Going to Happen (Part One of Morgan's Interview)
In this episode of "Stand Our Ground," host Kiah Penfield speaks with Morgan about the life and tragic murder of Morgan's sister, Deanna Stevison. Morgan reminisces about Deanna's nurturing role in her life and the nature of Deanna's relationship with her partner, Meghan. The discussion reveals Deanna's premonitions about her safety and the family's dissatisfaction with the investigation into her death, highlighting perceived systemic failures and overlooked evidence, such as suspicious text messages. The episode paints a picture of loss, love, and a quest for justice.
S2 E4 · Tue, February 06, 2024
S2 Episode 4: "I'm Scared That Meghan is Plotting Something"
Join us in this episode as we continue to dissect the perplexing relationship of Deanna and Meghan. We explore how text messages between the two paint a different picture leading up to the tragic events in June 2017 than the one told in Meghan's police interview. Digging into the evidence, we present an enhanced 911 call from inside the apartment, capturing the raw audio of the fatal incident. Surprisingly absent from the official records, this audio raises questions about the thoroughness of the police investigation. We also highlight a text message from Deanna expressing concern to her mother about Meghan plotting to reclaim the house. Listen to the email Deanna sent to Meghan, an overlooked element that establishes a crucial paper trail left behind by the victim. This episode sheds light on the discrepancies in Meghan's narrative, prompting us to reexamine the details surrounding Deanna's untimely end.
S2 E3 · Mon, January 29, 2024
S2 Episode 3: "It's All My Fault" (Text Messages Part 3)
Our final episode going through the text messages between Deanna and Meghan in the weeks leading up to Deanna's murder seems to show that Meghan was willing to try again. We also find out why Meghan thought she would get money when Deanna died and finally have proof to support the letter theory!
S2 E2 · Wed, January 24, 2024
S2 Episode 2: "Well Then Move" (Text Messages Part 2 and Enhanced 911 Call)
In this episode, we will continue diving through Deanna Stevison and Meghan Wojdyla (now Meghan Plunkett)'s text messages from the months leading up to Deanna's death. You'll also hear never-before-heard audio from one of the 911 calls, including the gunshots and the yelling between them. We can't wait to hear your thoughts on the call! Note: This episode contains a large amount of explicit language.
S2 E1 · Mon, January 15, 2024
S2 Episode 1: Text Messages (Part 1)
In this episode, we start diving into the text messages between Meghan Wojdyla (now Meghan Plunkett) and Deanna Stevison in the months before Deanna was killed. Next episode, we will continue going through the text messages and soon we'll talk about what I uncovered in one of the 911 calls!
S1 E12 · Tue, December 12, 2023
Episode 12: Where We’ve Been & Where We’re Going (Season 1 Recap)
In the final episode of season 1, we recap what we’ve learned so far and what we’re going to cover in our next season when we return from winter hiatus.
S1 E11 · Mon, December 04, 2023
Episode 11: Ricochet
In this episode, we discuss the bullet casings found at the scene and how the evidence relates to Deanna's case. Is it possible that a bullet ricocheted and hit Deanna? Are Deanna's gunshot wounds consistent with ricochet wounds? Gunshot wound information sourced from The University of Utah Eccles Health Sciences Library's Internet Pathology Laboratory for Medical Education.
S1 E10 · Mon, November 27, 2023
Episode 10: Chapter 776 (Florida Statutes)
In this episode, we look at Florida's "Stand Your Ground" law, what it says, how it changed the day after Deanna's death, and what it could mean for Deanna's case. Listen to Kiah on Phantom Electric Ghost podcast here. References: 2016 Florida Statutes Title XLVI, Chapter 776, Sections 776.012, 776.013, and 776.032 2023 Florida Statutes Title XLVI, Chapter 776, Sections 776.012, 776.013, and 776.032 "Recent Changes to the Florida Stand You Ground Law" by the Law Offices of Robert David Malove "What is Florida's 'Stand Your Ground' Law? Here are Five Questions (and Answers) to Explain" by Rachael Thomas "Florida Supreme Court Rules 2017 Stand Your Ground Law Change is No Retroactive" by Josh Solomon and Kathryn Varn
S1 E9 · Mon, November 20, 2023
Episode 9: “She Wanted to Die” (*Kelsey’s* Police Interview)
This episode contains a redacted version of the police interview with witness *Kelsey*, who shares that Amy and Meghan Plunkett claimed that Deanna “wanted to die.”
Trailer · Sun, November 12, 2023
Updated Trailer - Nov 2023
A new and improved trailer featuring clips from the show and the interviews we’ve done!
S1 E8 · Sun, November 12, 2023
Episode 8: The Investigator
In this episode, we discuss Investigator Jimmie Tatum and my concerns with how he ran the investigation. This episode includes some comments about Deanna that may be difficult to listen to, made by the investigator himself. This episode also features Tanner Condon as the voice of the investigative report, and a police interview with *Kelsie* (pseudonym). Some audio from Ollie Jane’s police interview is also used and video footage from the front dash cam is referenced.
Bonus · Sun, November 12, 2023
Bonus Episode: Response to TruRed Crime YouTube Video
This bonus episode features my response to the Nov. 10, 2023 TruRed Crime YouTube video about my cousin’s case. I address the inaccuracies in the video and the missing parts of the police interviews. Please share wherever you see the YouTube episode posted!
S1 E6 · Sun, November 05, 2023
Episode 7: Over My Dead Body
In this episode, we look into the timeline of the house that is at the center of this case, including the court case that allowed Meghan Wojdyla (now Meghan Plunkett) to assume full ownership of the house--which she and Amy Plunkett now live in together. Special thanks to voice actor Loki Cockrill! Sources Include: Police interview with witness "Kelsey" Personal email Interview with Griner Restraining order filing Facebook posts by Deanna Court case and property tax receipts for the Cantonment home bought by Deanna and Meghan Personal phone call with Deanna's mom, my Aunt Sheila
Bonus · Tue, October 31, 2023
Subscriber Bonus: Full Griner Interview
As thanks for your subscription, please enjoy my full interview with Griner, which includes several unheard pieces of audio that didn’t make it into the podcast.
S1 E6 · Mon, October 30, 2023
Episode 6: “I’ve Waited So Long to Get This Out” (Griner Interview - Part 2)
This episode features the second half of my interview with Griner, Deanna’s friend and coworker, and the last person to see her before she left for the Fairfield apartments where she was killed. In this episode, we discuss Deanna’s drinking that night, why Griner thinks Deanna left that morning, and some of what he knows of Deanna and Meghan’s relationship.
S1 E5 · Sun, October 22, 2023
Episode 5: “I’ll Be Here on the Couch When You Wake Up” (Griner Interview - Part 1)
I speak with Griner, a friend and coworker of Deanna’s who was with her the night of June 7 and morning of June 8, before she left for the Fairfield apartments. He will share his memories of Deanna’s last night. Subscribe to the podcast to receive access to the full interview once I’m done editing it.
S1 E4 · Sun, October 15, 2023
Episode 4: To Serve and Protect Who?
In this episode, I interview Jimmie Staley, the author of the Conjuring Justice blog. We discuss multiple instances of corruption in the Escambia County Sheriff’s Office and Jimmie’s thoughts on Deanna’s case. For references and evidence on the other cases Jimmie mentions, visit conjuringjusticeblog.com.
S1 E3 · Sun, October 08, 2023
Episode 3: It Won’t Change Anything
Join us for a deep dive into a complex case in the latest episode of Stand Our Ground. We will be exploring the complex and unsolved case of Deanna Stevison and discussing potential issues within the Escambia County Sheriff's Office. We will hear from a key witness named Skipper about the moments following the crime and discuss the differing accounts in the official narrative. Together, we'll examine witness testimonies, the conduct of investigators, and the Stevison family's ongoing search for the truth. This episode is not just a true crime story, it's a sobering look at the continued quest for justice in Deanna's memory. Join us, and remember—truth is the basis of our discussions, and justice is our objective. Voice actor Tanner Condon reads the investigative report. You can find Tanner Condon on Twitch @itztanny and TikTok @itztannytwitch. (Content Warning: This episode includes discussions of domestic violence and descriptions of a murder investigation which some listeners may find distressing. For support, please call the Mental Health Crisis Line at 988 in the U.S., or text HOME to 741741.) 🔍 #JusticeForDeanna #TrueCrimePodcast #StandOurGround Sources for this episode include the police interview with Skipper, my personal text conversation with her, my interviews with Jimmie Staley and Griner, and Jimmie Tatum’s investigative report. 🎧 You can listen to the episode now on Spotify - for bonus content, including a full text interview with witness Skipper, subscribe at the link in our bio.
Bonus · Sat, October 07, 2023
Correction to Episode 1
A brief correction about a detail from episode 1.
S1 E2 · Wed, October 04, 2023
Episode 2: “I’m a Murderer”
In this episode of Stand Our Ground, we sift through the aftermath of Deanna's murder. The police interviews with Meghan Wojdyla and the Plunketts, Amy and Ollie Jane, reveal a web of complex relationships and abuse allegations. A restraining order adds to the confusion, presenting more riddles than solutions. As we analyze the court documents versus the recounted events, the gaps in the investigation grow apparent, suggesting potential oversights that could have allowed vital details to slip through the cracks. We peel back the layers of that day's tension, questioning Amy's perplexing choice to disarm herself in the face of danger, and the role Deanna's alleged intoxication played in the tragic escalation. The accounts of what transpired diverge sharply, and as we dissect the moments that led to violence, it becomes clear that each decision carried weighty consequences. In the final segment of our episode, we shine a light on the sidelined testimony of a witness known only as Skipper. Previously dismissed, Skipper's observations gained notice only after social media brought them to light. We scrutinize the investigator's report alongside Skipper's account, seeking discrepancies and hidden truths. As we hold space for Deanna's voice, captured in a recording that humanizes the stark reality of loss, we invite listeners to join in the quest for clarity and justice, reminding us that each piece of the puzzle brings us closer to understanding the full scope of that fateful day. Information cited in this episode originated from redacted public records obtained from Escambia County Sheriff’s Office, including video of police interviews with Amy Plunkett, Meghan Wojdyla, and Ollie Jane Plunkett, Deanna’s autopsy report, Deanna’s toxicology report; and personal communications.
S1 E1 · Sun, October 01, 2023
Episode 1: Two Sides to Every Story
In this inaugural episode of "Stand Our Ground," host Kiah delves into the murder of her cousin, Deanna Stevison, introducing key figures involved: Deanna, a 31-year-old worker at Blackwater Correctional Institute; her ex-fiancée Meghan Wojdyla, a bank teller; Meghan's new fiancée, former sheriff's deputy Amy Plunkett; Amy's mother, Ollie Jane Plunkett; and lead investigator Jimmy Tatum. The episode outlines the conflicting narratives and relationships, including a restraining order and the questionable investigation, urging listeners to help seek justice for Deanna.
Trailer · Fri, September 01, 2023
Trailer - Stand Our Ground (Coming October 2023)
In 2017, my cousin Deanna Stevison was murdered. Everyone knows who was involved: my cousin’s ex-girlfriend, Meghan, Meghan’s new girlfriend, Amy, and Amy’s mom, Ollie Jane. Three hours after the murder, they all left the police station. No charges were ever filed. I still have a lot of questions. Who really shot my cousin? Did the police give Amy, a former cop, preferential treatment throughout the investigation? Is it coincidence that the murder happened on both Deanna and Meghan’s anniversary AND the day before Florida’s governor signed into law an amendment making it easier to claim a Stand Your Ground defense? But mostly, will we ever get justice for Deanna? Now, over six years later, join me as I dig through the case files and investigate what really happened to my cousin on Stand Our Ground, a new true crime podcast premiering October 2023 on Spotify.
loading...