Extinguished
Join us for this long form podcast about the murdered and missing. Long form because we will do one case in 4 weeks. Make sure to tune in each and every week so you do not miss an episode of the case.
S2 E8 · Sun, April 20, 2025
Jason Lierl The Chilling Unsolved Mystery Pt. 1
FORMAT 1: COMPREHENSIVE PROFESSIONAL🎙️ Episode Summary In the debut of Extinguished’s new series, hosts David McClam and Ladonna Humphrey investigate the baffling disappearance of Jason Lierl from Madison County, Arkansas, exploring the details surrounding his vanishing and the unanswered questions that haunt his case. Listen as they dissect the timeline, evidence, and potential theories behind Jason’s mysterious absence, seeking to bring his story to light. 00:00 Introduction to Extinguished 01:02 Who Was Jason Lierl? 02:25 The Disappearance 03:35 Investigation Insights 04:53 Online Theories and Speculation 05:37 The Human Element Examine the initial details of Jason Lierl's background and his last known whereabouts in January 2022. Analyze the significance of Jason’s abandoned car and scattered belongings found across Arkansas and Missouri. Consider the potential explanations for Jason’s disappearance, including drug relapse and possible foul play. Note the involvement of the FBI and the substantial rewards offered for information leading to Jason’s whereabouts. Understand the importance of community involvement in solving the case and providing closure to Jason’s family. FBI Reward: $30,000 reward for information on Jason Lierl’s whereabouts. [Details Needed] Sarah Wood’s Reward: $10,000 reward for information leading to Jason Lierl. [Details Needed]
S2 E7 · Sun, April 13, 2025
Evelyn Boswell: A Baby Betrayed Pt 4
In the final episode of the Evelyn Boswell series, David McClam and Ladonna Humphrey draw chilling parallels between the Boswell case and that of Casey Anthony, highlighting the disturbing similarities in the disappearances of young children and the mothers’ deceptive actions, while contrasting the vastly different courtroom outcomes. This episode explores themes of justice, deception, and the tragic loss of innocent lives. Timeline: 00:00 Introduction to Extinguished 00:27 The Comparison: Megan Boswell and Casey Anthony 01:44 How the Cases Unfolded 04:13 The Disturbing Discoveries 05:43 Courtroom Outcomes: A Tale of Two Trials 07:29 The Legacy of Evelyn and Kaylee Key Takeaways: Recognize the similarities in the disappearances of Kaylee Anthony and Evelyn Boswell, including delayed reporting and deceptive behaviors of the mothers. Understand the critical differences in the courtroom outcomes of Casey Anthony and Megan Boswell, despite the similar circumstances. Reflect on the failures within the justice system, emphasizing the importance of continued advocacy for victims of such crimes. Consider the devastating impact of lies and deception on investigations and the grieving process. Remember Evelyn Boswell and Kaylee Anthony, advocating for justice and awareness to prevent future tragedies.
S2 E6 · Mon, April 07, 2025
Evelyn Boswell: A Baby Betrayed Pt3
In this episode of Extinguished, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey continue their coverage of the Evelyn May Boswell case, diving into the trial of Megan Boswell, the verdict, and the sentencing. The hosts dissect the emotionally charged proceedings and the legal outcomes, emphasizing the gravity of the crimes committed against a defenseless child. TIME LINE [00:08] Introduction to the Evelyn May Boswell case conclusion. [00:36] Details of the trial against Megan Boswell. [01:55] The jury’s verdict on all charges. [02:30] Discussion of the sentencing trial. [03:12] Testimony from Megan Boswell’s mother, Angela Boswell. [03:55] Testimony from Megan’s former foster mother, Gail Kite. [04:51] Prosecution’s closing arguments. [05:38] Defense’s plea for mercy. [06:23] The jury’s sentencing decision. [07:02] Reflection on the case and its tragic consequences. [07:54] Call to action for listeners to report unsolved cases. KEY TAKEAWAYS Understand the impact of deception and neglect in cases of child murder. Recognize the complexities of sentencing, considering both justice and potential for redemption. Acknowledge the lasting impact of such tragedies on communities and families. Learn about the legal proceedings and the emotional toll they take on all involved. Emphasize the importance of speaking out and reporting suspicious activity to law enforcement.
Bonus · Tue, April 01, 2025
Death Fetish: Exposing the Truth the Internet Hides
In this episode of Extinguished, David McClam and Ladonna Humphrey dive into the disturbing world of death fetish, exploring its presence on the internet and the potential connections to real-world violence. They also revisit a past investigation that may have been compromised. Time Line: 00:00 Welcome to Extinguished 01:08 Unveiling Death Fetish 02:03 The Dark Industry of Death Fetish 03:27 Real-Life Consequences 04:11 Revisiting the Investigation 05:01 The Bombshell Revelation 05:40 The Quest for Truth Key Takeaways: Expose the dark underbelly of death fetish and its eroticization of violence against women. Understand the scale of death fetish content and the financial incentives driving its production. Recognize the potential for fantasy to cross into reality. Examine a previous investigation into death fetish and the reasons for reopening the case. Learn about “Snuff Princess” Jessica Brown’s claims regarding ownership of death fetish and gore sites.
S2 E5 · Sun, March 30, 2025
Evelyn Boswell: A Baby Betrayed Pt2
In this episode of Extinguished, David McClam and Ladonna Humphrey cover the tragic case of Evelyn May Boswell, a 15-month-old girl whose disappearance was masked by her mother’s lies and inconsistencies, leading to a devastating discovery. The hosts highlight the critical importance of truthfulness and swift action in missing children cases.
S2 E3 · Mon, March 24, 2025
Evelyn Boswell: A Baby Betrayed Pt. 1
A missing 15-month-old girl, a mother’s web of lies, and a community’s desperate search. Discover the tragic story of Evelyn Boswell, where secrets and deceit led to an unthinkable discovery, and explore the critical need for truth in cases of missing children. Chapter Summary: 00:00 Introduction to Extinguished 00:31 The Case of Evelyn Boswell 01:35 Conflicting Stories and Inconsistencies 03:00 The Discovery of Human Remains 04:56 Lessons Learned from a Tragic Case Featured Quotes: David McClam: “…the child whose disappearance was buried under months of lies had been there all along.” Ladonna Humphrey: “For months, Evelyn could have been found…maybe, just maybe, there could have been a different outcome.” Behind the Story: The Evelyn Boswell case highlights the devastating consequences of delayed reporting and dishonesty in missing persons investigations. The hosts examine how a mother’s false statements and shifting stories wasted precious time, ultimately leading to a tragic outcome that underscores the critical importance of immediate and truthful action when a child’s life is at stake.
S2 E7 · Sun, March 16, 2025
The Murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson Pt. 4
In this episode of Extinguished, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey broaden their focus to highlight numerous unsolved murders in Kitsap and Mason Counties, emphasizing the need for justice for all victims, not just the well-known cases. They discuss several forgotten cases, shedding light on the circumstances and urging anyone with information to come forward. The hosts provide contact information for the Bremerton Police Department and Crime Stoppers, reinforcing their commitment to seeking justice for the forgotten. If you have any information about the murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson and her daughter Adrienne Hill or any of the other cases please call: Bremerton Police Department: (360) 473-5228 Crime Stoppers: +1 800-222-TIPS Chapters 00:00 Introduction to Extinguished 00:19 The Unsolved Cases of Kitsap and Mason Counties 01:46 Barbara Williams: A Chilling Case 02:35 The Murder of Diane Decker 03:05 The Disappearance of Serena Marie Dingler 04:02 A History of Forgotten Cases 05:14 The Importance of Community Involvement Recognize the importance of remembering victims of unsolved murders. Understand the reasons why some cases remain cold, including lack of evidence and media attention. Encourage listeners to contact the Bremerton Police Department or Crime Stoppers with any information. Emphasize that justice should be available for all, not just a select few. Acknowledge that cold cases can be solved with new information.
S2 E6 · Sun, March 09, 2025
The Murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson Pt. 3
In this episode of Extinguished, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey continue their coverage of the 1986 murders of Nikki Anderson and her daughter, Adrienne Hill, highlighting a new DNA development that brings investigators closer to identifying the killer. Kenny Hale, Adrianne’s father, shares his ongoing grief and the desperate need for closure, as detectives seek a name to match the DNA evidence. Listen to learn how you can potentially help solve this cold case. If you have any information about the murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson and her daughter nAdrienne Hill, please call: Detective Martin Garland, Bremerton Police Department: (360) 473-5488 Crime Stoppers Tip Line: +1 800-222-TIPS Chapters 00:00 Introduction to Extinguished 00:31 A New Development in the Case 01:04 Kenny Hale’s Heartbreak 02:12 The Crime Scene 03:16 DNA Evidence and Its Limitations 04:40 The Nature of the Crime 05:19 The Search for Justice 06:29 Call to Action Key Takeaways Understand the latest DNA evidence in the Nikki Anderson and Adrianne Hill case. Recognize the significance of a single name in solving the crime. Empathize with Kenny Hale’s decades-long search for justice. Learn about the disturbing details of the murders and the betrayal involved. Discover how to provide information to Detective Marty Garland or Crime Stoppers.
S2 E6 · Sun, March 02, 2025
The Murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson Pt. 2
In this episode of Extinguished, hosts David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey delve into the tragic 1986 murders of Nikki Anderson and her daughter Adrienne Hill, focusing on the devastating experience of Kenny Hill, Adrienne’s father, who discovered their bodies. The episode explores the themes of trauma, grief, and the relentless pursuit of justice, highlighting the impact on Kenny’s life and the ongoing investigation. Listen to learn about the heartbreaking details and the lingering hope for a break in the case. If you have any information about the murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson and her daughter nAdrienne Hill, please call: Detective Martin Garland, Bremerton Police Department: (360) 473-5488 00:00 Introduction to Extinguished 00:29 Kenny Hill’s Heartbreaking Discovery 01:04 A Night of Normalcy Turns Tragic 02:09 The Horrific Discovery 03:25 The Aftermath of the Crime Scene 04:41 Suspicions and Investigations 05:39 A Decade of Waiting for Justice 06:44 Hope Amidst the Grief Key Takeaways Understand the initial police investigation and the impact on Kenny Hill David McClam, LaDonna Humphrey. Examine the challenges faced by investigators due to degraded DNA evidence David McClam, LaDonna Humphrey. Consider the emotional toll on family members affected by unsolved murder cases David McClam, LaDonna Humphrey. Recognize the importance of community involvement in solving cold cases David McClam, LaDonna Humphrey. Learn how to report information related to the Nikki Anderson and Adrienne Hill case David McClam, LaDonna Humphrey.
S2 E5 · Mon, February 24, 2025
The Murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson Pt.1
In this episode of Extinguished, hosts David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey cover the haunting unsolved 1986 murders of Nikki Anderson and her daughter, Adrienne Hill, in Bremerton, Washington. The case remains open, with investigators seeking new leads to bring justice for Nikki and Adrienne. If you have any information about the murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson and her daughter nAdrienne Hill, please call: Detective Martin Garland, Bremerton Police Department: (360) 473-5488 00:00 Introduction to Extinguished 00:20 The Victims: Nikki and Adrienne 01:08 The Night of the Tragedy 02:49 Investigation Insights 03:36 Advancements in DNA Technology 04:33 The Impact of Unsolved Crimes Key Takeaways Understand the details surrounding the 1986 murders of Nikki Anderson and Adrienne Hill. Learn about the initial suspects and how they were ruled out through alibis and DNA evidence. Discover the significance of unidentified DNA found at the crime scene and its potential for solving the case. Note the contact information for Detective Martin Garland and how to provide tips. Recognize the impact of unsolved cases on families and communities, advocating for continued efforts in seeking justice.
S2 E4 · Wed, February 19, 2025
The Murder Of Dana Stidham Ep. 4
In this episode of Extinguished, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey conclude their coverage of Dana Stidham’s murder and explore the tragic case of Amanda Tussing, questioning whether a potential serial killer could be responsible for both crimes. They discuss the similarities between the cases and a third unsolved murder, urging listeners to come forward with any information that might help bring justice to these women and their families. Time Line 00:00 Welcome to Extinguished 00:24 The Heartbreaking Case of Amanda Tussing 02:18 The Investigation Unfolds 03:35 Connecting the Dots 04:32 A Call for Justice 05:00 Previewing the Next Case Examine the details surrounding Amanda Tussing’s disappearance and murder in Jonesboro, Arkansas. Consider the theory that Amanda may have been pulled over by a police impersonator. Analyze the similarities between the murders of Dana Stidham, Amanda Tussing, and Patricia Gordaro. Discuss the possibility of a serial killer being responsible for these crimes. Encourage listeners to contact law enforcement with any information about these cases.
S2 E3 · Sun, February 09, 2025
The Murder of Dana Stidham Ep. 3
In this episode of “Extinguished,” hosts David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey explore the unsolved murder of 18-year-old Dana Stidham, who disappeared on July 25, 1989, in Bella Vista, Arkansas. Dana went missing during a quick grocery run, and her car was later found abandoned with signs that someone else had driven it. Her skeletal remains were discovered on September 17, 1989, but due to decomposition, it was unclear if she had been sexually assaulted. Several personal items and groceries were never recovered. Despite evidence collected, including scattered clothing and a magazine found near her belongings, no DNA has led to an arrest. In 2016, a suspect was named but not charged, and the case remains open with investigators seeking new information. The episode also touches on the upcoming episode on Helene Nikki Anderson’s murder, noting the lack of media coverage for cases involving marginalized communities. The hosts stress the importance of independent media in highlighting these issues and advocate for solving Dana’s case. They emphasize giving victims a voice and ensuring their stories are remembered. Key Points: Disappearance and Discovery: Dana Stidham disappeared during a routine grocery trip. Her father’s car was found abandoned with evidence suggesting another driver. Her skeletal remains were discovered nearly two months later, with significant decomposition complicating the investigation. Unresolved Evidence: Personal items and groceries were missing, and scattered clothing and a magazine were found near the scene. Despite evidence collection, no DNA has led to an arrest, leaving the case cold. Suspect and Investigation Status: A suspect was named in 2016, yet no charges have been filed. Investigators continue to seek new leads to solve the case. Upcoming Discussions: The episode hints at future coverage of Helene Nikki Anderson’s murder, highlighting the disparity in media attention for cases involving marginalized communities. Role of Independent Media: The hosts emphasize the critical role of independent media in bringing attention to underreported cases and advocating for justice. They underscore the importance of giving victims a voice and ensuring their stories are not forgotten. Listeners are encouraged to engage with the episode and consider the broader implications of media coverage in unsolved cases, particularly those affecting marginalized groups.
Sun, February 02, 2025
The Murder Of Dana Stidham PT. 2
Join us as we continue the deep dive into the murder of Dana Stidham
S2 E1 · Mon, January 27, 2025
The Murder of Dana Stidham Ep. 1
Join us as we look into this murder that has never been solved and justice is needed.
S2 Enull · Tue, January 21, 2025
We are back The Hiatus is OVER!!
The hiatus has come to an end. We are back and starting next week we will be back with full episodes. Listen to this short episode to find out more.
Mon, September 23, 2024
Ep29. Gone Without a Trace: The Perplexing Case of Clinton Nelson Pt. 3
In this episode of “Extinguished,” hosts LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam meticulously examine the disappearance of Clinton Nelson, who vanished under enigmatic circumstances in Princeton, Louisiana, on September 1, 2006. Clinton, aged 21, was last observed walking home from a party around midnight. Despite exhaustive searches conducted by law enforcement and his family, no substantial leads have surfaced, plunging his loved ones into profound uncertainty and grief. The discussion scrutinizes potential drug-related factors and emphasizes a stringent Louisiana statute that enforces severe penalties for those supplying drugs that result in death. This law may inadvertently deter individuals from disclosing information due to the fear of legal consequences, thereby stalling investigations by fostering a climate of fear within the drug community and perpetuating unresolved cases. The dialogue proposes various measures to incentivize the sharing of information, including the provision of immunity or reduced sentences, and the establishment of trust through harm reduction initiatives. It underscores the critical role of support and advocacy for families of missing persons, highlighting the significance of organizations that assist in navigating the legal landscape and enhancing public awareness. The utilization of anonymous tip lines is suggested as a method to gather information without imposing legal ramifications. The narrative emphasizes the relentless efforts of Clinton’s mother, Carolyn, who has been an unwavering advocate for her son since his disappearance. It stresses the paramount importance of public awareness and collective support in resolving such cases, urging anyone with pertinent information to contact the Bossier Parish Sheriff’s Office or reputable advocacy organizations, as even minor tips could prove to be pivotal. If you have any information on the dissaperence of Clinton Nelson Bossier parish sheriff office 318- 965-2203 318 424 4100 Bossier Crime Stoppers 318-424-4100 Time Line 00:00 Introduction to Extinguished 01:10 The Disappearance of Clinton Nelson 02:16 The Impact of Drug Activity 03:20 Understanding Louisiana’s Drug Laws 05:01 Fear and Silence Surrounding Clinton’s Case 07:04 Potential Solutions for Encouraging Cooperation 09:01 The Role of Advocacy and Support 12:30 Call to Action for Listeners Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David
Sun, July 14, 2024
Ep28. Gone Without a Trace: The Perplexing Case of Clinton Nelson Pt. 2
David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey present the case of Clinton Devon Nelson, who mysteriously disappeared in 2006 after stepping outside a party in Princeton, Louisiana to smoke. Despite injuries from a recent work accident and lacking transportation or financial resources, Nelson vanished under suspicious circumstances.His last phone activity indicated paranoia likely induced by drug use, and he had a history of substance abuse, including a recent arrest for drug possession. The house where he was last seen had sophisticated surveillance equipment, raising questions about what was recorded and potential foul play. The neighborhood’s reputation and presence of drug dealers add to the suspicions. Various theories about Nelson’s fate include abduction, murder, accidental death, or a drug overdose. The narrative also mentions unreported incidents due to fear, hinting at possible foul play involving significant money Nelson had that night. If you have any information on the dissaperence of Clinton Nelson Bossier parish sheriff office 318- 965-2203 318 424 4100 Bossier Crime Stoppers 318-424-4100 Time Line 00:00 Introduction and Recap 01:00 The Bizarre Circumstances of Clinton's Disappearance 02:22 Speculations and Theories 06:43 The Most Likely Scenario: Accidental Drug Overdose 09:33 The Last Contact and Unanswered Questions 10:01 Closing Remarks and Future Episodes Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.
Sun, May 19, 2024
Ep27. Gone Without a Trace: The Perplexing Case of Clinton Nelson Pt. 1
We delve into the mysterious disappearance of Clinton Devon Nelson in September 2006, a young man from Nebraska who went missing after trying to reconnect with his biological father in Louisiana. Despite a hopeful beginning, including a job offer and plans to live with his father, Clinton’s story took a dark turn when he vanished following an encounter at a friend’s house, where his stepfather Jeff last saw him peering through blinds. Clinton had a history that included a drug possession charge and an outstanding arrest warrant for missing a court date, but his sudden disappearance left many unanswered questions. His family firmly believed he wouldn’t have left voluntarily, especially since he was excited about upcoming fatherhood and left behind his paycheck. Investigations revealed drug activity at the friend’s house Clinton visited, linking it to methamphetamine distribution, and suggested Clinton might have been using heavy narcotics, possibly leading to paranoia and erratic behavior. Despite extensive searches and theories ranging from voluntary departure to drug-induced disorientation or even foul play, Clinton’s fate remains unknown. LaDonna along with Amy Smith, participated in search efforts and are working on a documentary to bring attention to Clinton’s case, hoping for closure and justice. They encourage listeners to provide any information to authorities. If you have any information on the dissaperence of Clinton Nelson Bossier parish sheriff office 318- 965-2203 318 424 4100 Bossier Crime Stoppers 318-424-4100 Time Line 00:00 Introduction to Extinguished David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey introduce the podcast Extinguished, focusing on sharing stories of the missing and murdered. 00:20 Background of Clinton DeVaughn Nelson Details about Clinton’s family background, his relationships, and his decision to move to Louisiana to reconnect with his father. 02:01 Events Leading to Clinton’s Disappearance Description of the events leading up to Clinton’s disappearance, including his job injury, financial situation, and interactions with family members. 05:54 Theories and Suspicious Circumstances Exploration of theories surrounding Clinton’s disappearance, including drug activity, paranoia, and potential foul play. 07:11 Search Efforts and Personal Experience Discussion about the ground searches conducted, the intensity of searching for a missing person, and personal experiences during the search for Clinton. 11:00 Unsolved Case and Ongoing Efforts Overview of Clinton’s case remaining unsolved, ongoing efforts such as the documentary, and the importance of finding closure for the family. Get your tickets for True CrimeFest <a href="https://www.truecrimefestnwa.com/event-details-registration/true-crime-fest-2024" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer no
Sun, May 12, 2024
Ep26. In Pursuit of Truth for Deanna Stevison's Unsolved Murder Pt. 6
LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam continue their discussion on the death of Deanna Stevenson in Escambia County, Florida. They believe that Deanna's death was not a justifiable homicide under Florida's Stand Your Ground law, but rather a murder. They highlight inconsistencies in the story surrounding Deanna's death and the misapplication of the Stand Your Ground law. They call for Escambia County authorities to reopen and reinvestigate the case. The episode ends with a plea to listeners to join them in demanding accountability and justice for Deanna. Escambia County DA/County Attorney Alison Rogers 850-595-4970 email legal@myescambia.cp, Time Line 00:00 Introduction to the Case 00:41 Tragedy Strikes: Deanna's Death 03:21 Reopening and Reinvestigation 06:26 The Emotional State of Deanna and Megan 08:13 The Setup and Murder 13:28 Demanding Accountability and Justice 16:02 Closing Remarks and Call to Action Be sure to tune into Stand Our Ground with Kiah Penfield HERE Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.
Sun, May 05, 2024
Ep25. In Pursuit of Truth for Deanna Stevison's Unsolved Murder Pt. 5
In this episode, the hosts conclude their discussion on the Deanna Stevenson murder trial with special guest Kiah from the Stand Our Ground podcast. They focus on the former employment of one of the women involved in the case and her relationship with the lead investigator. They question why the lead investigator did not recuse himself and why the sheriff's office did not let the local police department handle the case. They also discuss the corruption in Escambia and Santa Rosa counties and the questionable decisions made by the sheriff's office. The hosts express their concerns about the stand your ground claim in Deanna's case and the gunshot pattern that suggests she was running away. They also mention the possibility that Megan and Amy were aware that Deanna would be out with friends and drinking before inviting her over. In this part of the conversation, the hosts and Kiah discuss the evidence surrounding the letters and the theory that Deanna was going to pick up a letter on the night she was killed. They explore the text messages and emails between Deanna and Megan, as well as the overheard conversation between Amy and Megan about Deanna going for Megan's purse. They also discuss the possibility that the events of that night were a setup and express frustration with the lack of proper investigation. Kiah shares her feelings of uncertainty and the difficulty of not having closure. The hosts express their dedication to the case and their determination to seek justice for Deanna. Time Line Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Recap 01:25 Former Employment and Relationship with Lead Investigator 05:28 Corruption in the Sheriff's Offices 09:14 Escambia County's Troubles 11:21 Controversial Statement by Sheriff Bob Johnson 13:33 Doubts About the Stand Your Ground Claim 20:51 Concerns About the Gunshot Pattern 21:22 The Evidence Surrounding the Letters 22:31 Text Messages and Emails: Clues to Deanna's Intentions 23:56 Overheard Conversations: The Purse and the Letter 28:27 The Theory of a Setup 29:52 Frustration with the Lack of Investigation 32:16 Living with Uncertainty and the Search for Closure 36:41 Dedication to Seeking Justice for Deanna Be sure to tune into Stand Our Ground with Kiah Penfield HERE Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith <a href="https://www.truecrimeandauthors.com/episodes/" tar
Mon, April 22, 2024
Ep24. In Pursuit of Truth for Deanna Stevison's Unsolved Murder Pt. 4
LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam, discuss the troubling murder case of Deanna Stevison, who was fatally shot entering an apartment, a case that has raised significant questions about Florida’s stand your ground law. The law, which was not challenged in Deanna’s case due to its provisions, has been criticized for not improving public safety and potentially exacerbating racial disparities. The circumstances surrounding Deanna’s death—her estrangement from her fiancée and the involvement of a former police officer—underscore concerns about the potential misuse of such laws. Despite Deanna expressing fears for her safety, the motives behind her shooting, and the details of her visiting someone’s house to pick up a letter, suggest investigators may have overlooked key elements. The broader misuse of stand your ground laws across the United States is highlighted, showing how they can lead to deadly outcomes in various scenarios, including disputes and custody battles. These laws have sometimes enabled aggressors and law enforcement officers to justify deadly force improperly. Furthermore, individuals such as women in abusive relationships and people of color often find it challenging to effectively use these laws in their defense. The case of Marissa Alexander is particularly noted, where her claim under the law was initially rejected despite facing violence, leading to a conviction later overturned on appeal. The podcast also critiques the investigation efforts by the Escambia County sheriff’s office and calls for a reconsideration of stand your ground laws in Florida and elsewhere. They argue these laws might protect individuals who claim self-defense in situations where harm could have been avoided. With a focus on statistics from Florida and examples from Arizona and Tallahassee, the conversation underscores instances where claims of self-defense were questionable. The speakers express frustration over the lack of thorough investigation and proper application of the law in cases like Deanna’s, advocating for a reevaluation of such cases and a rewriting of the laws to prevent further injustices and ensure justice is served. The text concludes with an encouragement for listeners to engage with the content and stay updated on developments, hinting at future discussions on the topic. Time Line 00:00 Introduction to Extinguished David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey introduce the podcast Extinguished, focusing on sharing stories of the missing and murdered. 00:20 Deanna Stevison Murder Case Recap A brief recap of the Deanna Stevison murder case, highlighting the tragic events leading to her death and the decision not to file charges under Florida stand your ground law. 01:28 Critique of Stand Your Ground Laws Discussion on the ineffectiveness and harmful impact of stand your ground laws, with insights from a study and expert opinio
Mon, April 15, 2024
Ep23. In Pursuit of Truth for Deanna Stevison's Unsolved Murder Pt. 3
Uncovering the complex layers of Deanna Stevison's case, LaDonna Humphrey and I, David McClam, return to the heart of a legal enigma—Florida's Stand Your Ground law. As we dissect the decision that left Deanna's death uncharged, we expose the critical nuances of her high blood alcohol content and its potential role in the fatal night's events. Deanna's BAC, well above the legal threshold, prompts us to challenge the accepted narrative and explore the broader consequences of driving under the influence. This episode unfolds a sobering discussion on the intricate dance between autonomy, accountability, and the law. In our continued pursuit of truth, the episode shifts focus to the reopened door to Deanna, a pivotal moment enveloped in ambiguity. Listen closely as we trace the contours of Deanna, Amy, and Megan's tangled relationship through texts and emails, contemplating the possibility of provocation. The bullet's trajectory speaks volumes, questioning the self-defense claim and the application of the Stand Your Ground law. With forensic evidence in hand, we probe the implications of a door ajar and a car left running, piecing together a narrative that may just tip the scales of justice. Join us as we commit to shedding light on the darkness surrounding Deanna's story, with the hope of propelling her case back into the eyes of the law. Time Line ( 00:01) Alcohol Levels and Stand Your Ground (10:51) Controversy Surrounding Stand Your Ground Law (24:31) Stand Your Ground Defense Challenges Get your tickets to True Crime Fest Arkansas HERE Be sure to tune into Stand Our Ground with Kiah Penfield HERE Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US
Sun, March 31, 2024
Easter Break Back Next Week
Easter gatherings with family have a special way of putting things into perspective. As LaDonna and I exchange stories with our loved ones, we're reminded of the powerful narratives that each of us carries. This week, our podcast takes a momentary rest to honor these personal tales and the Easter holiday, but we're poised to renew our deep-dive into the intriguing and complex case of Deanna Stevison when we return. The saga's twists and unexpected turns demand our full attention, and we're committed to bringing you along for this important journey. During this brief hiatus, it's the perfect opportunity for both newcomers and seasoned listeners to acquaint themselves with the details that make Deanna's story so compelling. Your unwavering engagement and thoughtful insights are the heartbeat of Extinguished, propelling us forward in our quest for justice. So, as we savor this time of reflection and celebration, we invite you to reflect on the episodes that have moved and challenged you. Come next week, we'll be ready to greet you with fresh resolve and the next chapter in our relentless pursuit of the truth. Be sure to tune into Stand Our Ground with Kiah Penfield HERE Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.
Sun, March 24, 2024
BONUS: In Pursuit of Truth for Deanna Stevison's Unsolved Murder
Embark on a journey through the twists and turns of the Deanna Stevison case with LaDonna and I as we confront the wave of misinformation head-on. Prepare to witness our unwavering commitment to truth as we dissect the unsettling allegations thrown at us, and our podcast, by a mysterious email correspondent. We stand firm against intimidation and uphold the facts, offering clarity to you, our dedicated listeners, while emphasizing our dedication to the integrity of our investigative work. This episode takes a deep look into the complexities surrounding Florida's 'stand your ground' law and its implications on the tragic shooting of Deanna. Through a careful examination of the evidence and the law's nuances, we aim to illuminate the shadowy lines between self-defense and unwarranted violence. The discovery of the weapon near the sink raises haunting questions, and we're here to ask them, ensuring that no stone is left unturned in our pursuit of the unvarnished truth. Lastly, we address the controversy sparked by the enigmatic Marty and his/her relentless emails. Our investigation into his/her identity is more than mere curiosity; it's a quest to understand his/her connection to the case and the impact of his/her actions on Deanna's grieving family. With empathy at the forefront, we strive to honor Deanna's memory, seek answers for her loved ones, and navigate the legal and ethical responsibilities that accompany our role as storytellers in the true crime community. Time Line (00:01) Addressing Misinformation in Extinguished Podcast (13:04) Stand Your Ground Law Discussion (23:31) Deanna's Shooting (35:05) Addressing Controversy Surrounding Marty's Emails (44:41) True Crime Podcast Promotion and Reminder Be sure to tune into Stand Our Ground with Kiah Penfield HERE Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION <a href="https://www.change.or
Sun, March 17, 2024
Ep22. In Pursuit of Truth for Deanna Stevison's Unsolved Murder Pt. 2
Uncover the chilling truth behind Deanna Stevison's untimely demise as we scrutinize the perplexing decision to not press charges. The echoes of gunshots and a life lost too soon reverberate through our latest episode, challenging the self-defense claim under the controversial Stand Your Ground Law. We wrestle with the official narrative and the heartache of Deanna's family, who remember her as anything but confrontational. Join us on a journey through a labyrinth of legal nuances and gut-wrenching 911 calls that leave more questions than answers. Feel the weight of the silence that followed the harrowing events of June 8, 2017, through the lens of critical 911 recordings we've analyzed. The eerie calm of a car left running, its driver never to return, paints a haunting picture of what was supposed to be a brief apartment visit. We scrutinize the inconsistencies between Ollie Plunkett's statements and the visceral reality that the emergency calls captured, shedding light on the enigma of Deanna's alleged aggression and the calculated decision to answer a door with a gun at the ready. As the investigation unfolds, we dissect the puzzling movement of Deanna's body and the chaotic decision-making in those critical moments. Stitching together the fabric of Deanna's character with her intentions on that fateful day, we invite you to engage with us in a quest for clarity. Every layer of this mystery unraveled brings us closer to understanding the dire implications of Stand Your Ground Laws when lives hang in the balance. Stay tuned as we question everything and seek to keep the flame of justice burning for Deanna Stevison. Time Line (00:01) Investigating the Deanna Stevenson Case (04:21) Discussion on Apartment Shooting Incident (11:14) 911 Calls and Crime Scene Analysis (22:12) Deep Dark Secrets Podcast Promotions Be sure to tune into Stand Our Ground with Kiah Penfield HERE Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith <a href="https://www.truecrimeandauthors.com/episodes/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener"
Sun, March 10, 2024
Ep21. In Pursuit of Truth for Deanna Stevison's Unsolved Murder Pt. 1
The quest for truth can often take us down the darkest of alleys, where the faintest glimmers of light beckon the brave. Today, we are joined by Kiah Penfield, whose tireless advocacy through her podcast Stand Our Ground brings us face to face with such a journey: the unsolved homicide of her cousin Deanna Stevison. As we explore Deanna's life, from her days as a corrections officer and devoted mother, to the chilling events leading up to her tragic death, we're reminded that every story is a tapestry of complexities, woven with threads of joy, pain, and sometimes, injustice. The heart of our conversation lies in dissecting the turbulent relationship between Deanna and her partner Megan—a narrative marred by manipulation and control. We witness how the scales tipped with financial shifts and how Megan's interactions with Deanna's son sent alarm bells ringing. Kiah's poignant accounts cast a new lens on the case, urging us to consider the unseen battles fought behind closed doors. As we sift through the layers of this case, we cannot ignore the unsettling efforts to discredit our discussions, pointing to a larger web of manipulation extending beyond a single relationship. Finally, we step into the shadows of a police investigation that appears to be riddled with more questions than answers. From missing files to interrogation discrepancies, the integrity of the Escambia Police Department's handling of Deanna's case is called into question. We grapple with the painful possibility of a cover-up and the painful implications it may have on the quest for justice. Kaya's determination to reopen and reinvestigate the case, coupled with our examination, serves as a clarion call for accountability and truth. The path to justice for Deanna may be fraught with obstacles, but it's a path we walk together, propelled by the hope that the truth will emerge from the shadows to honor her memory. Time Line (00:01) Unsolved Case of Deanna Stevenson (05:34) Relationship Manipulation and Escalation (17:36) Deanna's Shooting (25:22) Mystery Surrounding Shooting Incident (30:06) Confusion and Manipulation in Police Interview (34:40) Uncovering Alleged Police Corruption in Escambia (39:52) Investigative File Discrepancies and Concerns (45:26) Potential Cover-Up in Murder Investigation (54:08) Justice for Mishandled True Crime Case (01:02:06) Seeking Justice for Deanna Be sure to tune into Stand Our Grounf with Kiah Penfield HERE Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 1
Sun, March 03, 2024
Ep20. Where Dreams Fade The Cleashindra Hall Mystery Pt.4
As we draw the curtains on our four-part series, the enigmatic case of Cleashindra Denise Hall's disappearance reaches a critical juncture. We tackle the complexities and share our candid thoughts on why Dr. Larry Amos's involvement demands closer scrutiny. This episode teases out the unsettling chain of events on the day Cleashindra was last seen, coupled with our analysis of her employer's actions and what they could mean for this cold case that's chilled Pine Bluff, Arkansas since 1994. With a timeline that feels like the script of a heart-wrenching thriller, we retrace Cleashindra's steps from the moment she was dropped off at her place of work, to the disconcerting silence after her final phone call home. The urgency felt by Cleashindra's family as the night wore on without her return is palpable in our discussion, as is their dawning realization of her absence. Join us for this compelling episode that promises not just to narrate a story, but to honor the memory of a young woman whose fate remains a mystery, urging those who hold the missing pieces forward to finally shed light on the darkness of uncertainty. Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.
Mon, February 26, 2024
Ep19. Where Dreams Fade The Cleashindra Hall Mystery Pt.3
Unraveling the truth can be as perplexing as it is vital, especially when it comes to the cold case of Cleashindra Denise Hall. We crack open the baffling narrative surrounding her disappearance and zero in on the contradictory accounts of her last known employer, the enigmatic Dr. Amos. A detail as small as a can of peach pop becomes a significant lead, raising our suspicions and leading us to question the actions—or inactions—of those involved on the night she vanished. The perplexities compound as we tackle the strange phone call to a person named Smith and the unsettling hesitance of the police to probe further into the calls made from the Amos residence. The shadows of racial bias loom over the investigation of Clea's disappearance, casting a somber tone on our discussion. Delving into Pine Bluff's historical racial tensions, we contemplate how these may have marred the search for answers in the case of this 18-year-old girl. Confronted with the eerie premonitions of Clea's mother and the unnerving speculations about connections to the notorious Samuel Little, we grapple with the frustration that comes with a trail gone cold. Despite the accumulation of suspicious behavior and conjecture, the absence of charges against Dr. Amos leaves us with lingering questions and a determination to shine a light on a mystery that yearns for resolution. Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) F
Sun, February 18, 2024
Ep 18. Where Dreams Fade The Cleashindra Hall Mystery Pt. 2
When darkness fell on Pine Bluff, Arkansas, so too did a shadow over the future of Cleashindra Denise Hall, an 18-year-old at the cusp of her valedictorian success. We unravel the enigma of her 1994 disappearance after a seemingly ordinary evening at her employer Dr. Larry Amos's home office morphed into an enduring mystery. The silence that followed her last phone call home at 8 pm speaks volumes, as we scrutinize the puzzling behavior of Dr. Amos and the investigative challenges posed by an era of limited technology. With an alarmingly prompt late-night phone response, Amos's actions that night cast a long, unsettling shadow over the unanswered questions that linger. The plot thickens with the case .With graduation within reach and not a single sign pointing to a planned departure, this chapter dissects the delayed pursuit for truth and the web of contradictions spun by Dr. Amos himself. His resistance to aiding the investigation further fuels the whisperings of malfeasance. Amplifying the disquiet, we reveal chilling allegations of abuse within the Amos household, adding a sinister twist to the already complex narrative of these heartbreaking disappearances. Join us as we navigate this labyrinth of secrets. Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.
Sun, February 11, 2024
Ep 17. Where Dreams Fade The Cleashindra Hall Mystery Pt. 1
The shadows of a heartbreaking mystery from Pine Bluff, Arkansas, envelop our latest episode as we share the unresolved story of Cleashindra Denise Hall, known to her loved ones as Clea. It was 1994, a time of celebration turned to anguish when Clea disappeared the night before her high school graduation. We unfold layers of this narrative, reflecting on the family's unwavering strength, their emphasis on education, and the dreams of a young woman destined for a career in pediatric medicine—a potential tragically cut short. As we piece together the last known moments of Clea's life, we can't help but express our dismay at the initial investigation's missteps. We scrutinize the actions of a young man once questioned and the disturbing findings from a belated search at the non-profit where Clea worked, instigating a conversation about the critical first hours of a missing person's case. With each detail, Clea's memory is honored, and her family's enduring search for truth is brought to the forefront. This episode is a poignant journey through hope, despair, and the ongoing quest for answers that have eluded Clea's loved ones for far too long. Join us as we keep her story alive, continuing to search for the missing pieces in the enigmatic puzzle of Cleashindra Hall's disappearance. Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.
Sun, February 04, 2024
EP 16. Lost to the Shadows The Story of Nicole and Arianna Fitts Pt. 4
As the haunting melody of hope and heartbreak crescendos, we reach the poignant finale of Ariana Fitts's story in our latest Extinguished episode.We unravel the chilling turns in the search for the missing toddler and the quest for justice for her slain mother, Nicole "Nicky" Fitts. The fervor is reignited with a staggering $250,000 reward offer and the release of an age-progressed image by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, shedding light on the possibility that little Arianna might still be drawing breath in a world that's kept her hidden for too long. The final chapter of our series calls upon you, our listeners, to join a vigilant collective, poised to share Arianna's image far and wide, transforming every listener into a beacon of hope. We dig into the crucial roles of the community, the FBI's widening search net, and the enigmatic babysitter Helena Martin, her husband David, and her sister—key figures in the days leading up to Nicky's tragic death and Arianna's vanishing. In an appeal to the collective conscience, we remind you that your eyes and ears could be the catalyst for a breakthrough. Your action can help write an ending to this story—one we hope brings Ariana home. To read more about the case, visit the Charley Project HERE Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam
Mon, January 29, 2024
EP 15. Lost to the Shadows The Story of Nicole and Arianna Fitts Pt. 3
Unravel the chilling narrative of Nicole and Ariana Fitts as we continue our compelling investigation. In our latest installment, the perplexing details emerge from the shadows, including Helena Martin's ominous past and the staggering 30,000 pieces of evidence yet to crack the case. We're left grappling with a haunting question: Could the Martins, shrouded in their silence, hold the key to unlocking the fate of little Ariana and solving Nicole's brutal murder? With hearts heavy and minds resolute, we recount Nicole's unwavering dedication as a mother and the wrenching void left by her tragic end and Ariana's unresolved disappearance. We dissect the dark theories that swirl around Ariana's fate and the vital six-week period when mother and daughter were painfully parted. From possible family entanglements to the sinister underbelly of child trafficking, each theory is explored with the hope that forensic science might finally illuminate the path to answers. As the mystery unfolds, we honor Nicole's memory and rally our listeners: your voice could be the catalyst for justice in the haunting search for Arianna To read more about the case, visit the Charley Project HERE Get you tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.
Sun, January 21, 2024
EP 14. Lost to the Shadows The Story of Nicole and Arianna Fitts Pt. 2
A dark past surfaces as we peel back the layers of a mother's trust gone tragically wrong. Amidst the heartbreak of Nicole Fitts's murder and her daughter Ariannas mysterious disappearance, we reveal the disturbing history of Helena Martin—one of the last to see Arianna and a figure with a former murder charge haunting her narrative. The threads of misplaced trust weave a perplexing web as we discuss Nicole's dire situation as a vulnerable, single, homeless mother and the fateful decisions that led to her untimely death. The search for clarity intensifies when examining the peculiar actions of the Martins and their dubious Disneyland alibi, contrasted against the backdrop of Nicole's desperate fight to reclaim her daughter. As Goyette Williams recounts the final days before Nicole's disappearance, a cryptic text and a symbol-laden plywood board at the crime scene emerge as enigmatic clues. We scrutinize every angle, from the shaky stories to the chilling possibility that Arianna's vanishing was no accident. Join us for a meticulous analysis as we strive to piece together the harrowing events that have left a young girl missing and a family in anguish. To read more about the case, visit the Charley Project HERE Get you tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From
Sun, January 14, 2024
EP 13. Lost to the Shadows The Story of Nicole and Arianna Fitts Pt. 1
Uncover the heartache and mystery shrouding Nicole Fitts's tragic end and her daughter Arianna 's disappearance in our latest episode of Extinguished. As we recount the grim discovery in McLaren Park that marked only the beginning of this saga, the unsettling details of their story emerge—from Nicole's battle with poverty and homelessness to the murky figures that entered her life in its final chapters. We pay tribute to their memory, piecing together the fragments left behind, and hope to spark the conversations that could bring answers to a family still searching for closure. Listen as we navigate the complexities surrounding Nicole's relationships, including her involvement with a "street pastor" who may have been more foe than friend. We scrutinize the distressing signals that arose after Nicole's demise: cryptic text messages, a suspicious Facebook status, and the haunting realization that her daughter Arianna 's whereabouts remain an enigma. With every word, we aim to honor Nicole and Arianna Fitts, and through this narrative, we invite you to join us in seeking the truth behind a loss that reverberates to this day. To read more about the case, visit the Charley Project HERE Get you tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr </
Mon, January 08, 2024
Ep 12. In Pursuit of Justice: The Melissa Witt Story: The Conclusion
As the curtain falls on our deep dive into the chilling case of Melissa Witt, we're left grappling with the weight of unsolved mysteries and the shadows they cast. Join us for our final installment, where LaDonna unveils her conviction that Melissa's killer was no stranger, but someone within her inner circle, buried in the pages of her diary. Our discussion traverses the delicate intricacies of the FBI's killer profile and why suspects such as Larry Swearingen still linger in the periphery of possibility—highlighting the enigma that has endured nearly three decades. The triumph over adversity is palpable as we recount the odyssey behind our independent documentary's creation, celebrating its resonance with audiences at Crime Con and on platforms like YouTube and Amazon Prime. The unexpected success has not only ushered in a stream of crucial tips but also amplified public intrigue. Accompanying this surge, LaDonna's book "The Girl I Never Knew," has woven a tapestry of financial support and connections that extend far beyond the pages, fostering a community deeply invested in justice for Melissa. Amidst the breakthroughs, the personal toll of such a pursuit can't be overlooked. Reflecting on the impact writing "Strangled" has had on LaDonna's life, She navigates the dichotomy of contributing meaningfully to a cause while safeguarding her privacy and well-being. Yet even as we battle darkness, we find light in the form of solidarity against death fetishism and the anticipation of a third book that promises to unravel more mysteries of Melissa's case. Our conversation is a testament to the power of collaboration and shared passion, affirming that even in the most tragic stories, connection and purpose can be found. TIME LINE (00:01) Extinguished (09:48) Documentary Success and Writing Books (25:40) Writing Books and Fighting Death Fetish (33:18) Connection and Collaboration Get you tickets for True CrimeFest HERE Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON <a h
Sun, December 31, 2023
Ep 11. In Pursuit of Justice: The Melissa Witt Story: The line of Suspects
Unlock the shadowy maze of suspects surrounding the haunting case of Melissa Witt's unsolved murder with us, LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam. This episode peels back the layers of deceit and confessions, leading us through a chilling gallery of individuals whose past actions cast a long, dark shadow over the investigation. As we share our personal encounters and exclusive interviews, you'll feel the icy grip of possibility that one of these men could hold the key to a decades-long mystery. With each story, we reveal the intricate web of evidence and alibis that have both hindered and propelled the case forward. Extensive conversations with these individuals, including a 40-hour deep dive with a suspect, will leave you pondering the true nature of innocence and guilt. And when we explore the unsettling ties to the Baptist Vista Church Camp, the proximity to the crime scene sends a shiver down the spine of the community's collective memory. As the year comes to a close, join us in a heartfelt tribute to the victims and the stories that continue to echo in the silence of unresolved tragedies. This episode serves as a poignant reminder of the lives that have been altered by such crimes, and our commitment to seeking truth and justice. We share a solemn farewell, but not goodbye, as we promise to return with more untold stories of the missing and murdered. Stay vigilant, stay informed, and may the new year bring renewed hope and answers. TIME LINE (00:01) Unsolved Murders and Suspects (09:44) Suspects in Melissa Witt Investigation (19:46) Church Camp and Travis as Suspect (29:15) True Crime Podcast Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr
Sun, December 24, 2023
The Covina Massacre: A Holiday Horror Story Unveiled
A Christmas Eve celebration turns into a scene straight out of a horror film when a man clad as Santa Claus knocks on the Ortega family's door, unleashing terror beyond imagination. Listen as we, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey, unravel the Covina Massacre—a night that turned the joyous holiday into a nightmare of gunfire and flames, claiming nine innocent lives. As we recount the story in a complete single episode, we shed light on the devastating actions of Bruce Jeffrey Pardo, the family member whose malicious intent was disguised under the veil of a festive costume. Through eyewitness accounts and a detailed investigation, we expose the darkness that lurked behind Pardo's eyes and the calculated vengeance that led to an unfathomable tragedy. Join us for a poignant episode that serves as a stark reminder of the fragility of life and the sometimes hidden perils that can shatter the peace of the holiday season. Listen to the other Collaborators on Santa Maybe a Criminal. Click Here Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr
Sun, December 17, 2023
Ep 10. In Pursuit of Justice: The Melissa Witt Story: Suspect Larry Swearingen
Join us, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey, on Extinguished, as we peel back the layers of the haunting, unsolved 1994 murder case of Melissa Witt from Fort Smith, Arkansas. Listen in as we share how a rookie reporter, Marcus Blair, made an unexpected connection between Witt's murder and another chilling case in Texas. We discuss the eerie similarities between these two cases and the chilling evidence that pointed investigators towards a suspect named Larry Swearingen. Unravel with us, the complex web of clues that linked Swearingen to the Witt case, including his mysterious presence in Arkansas just days before Witt's murder. In the second part of the episode, we explore the dark and disturbing history of Larry Swearingen, a man whose violent past makes him a prime suspect. Swearingen, who was convicted and executed for another murder, maintained a disturbing silence about the Witt case, even going as far as sending threatening letters to one of the hosts. We also look into the case of Melissa Trotter, another young woman who was tragically murdered, and discuss the potential links between her case and Melissa Witt's. Tune in to uncover the mystery of these interconnected murder cases and the shadowy figure at their center. TIME LINE (00:01) Suspects in Melissa Witt Murder (16:57) Larry Swearingen's Dangerous Crimes (25:35) Melissa Witt Case Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr
Sun, December 10, 2023
Ep 9.. In Pursuit of Justice: The Melissa Witt Story: The Interview
Today, we're turning back the clock to 1994; the year a vibrant, young woman, Melissa Ann Witt, was tragically ripped from her loving family and community in Fort Smith, Arkansas. Embarking on an emotionally charged journey with us is Ladonna Humphrey, a seasoned investigator who has been wrapped up in Melissa's unsolved murder for the past eight years. LaDonna, also an acclaimed author and filmmaker, will walk us through the heartbreaking events of that fateful December day, the ongoing investigation, and Melissa's life that was cut short in the blink of an eye. We're also illuminating the relentless dedication of a retired detective, Jay C. Rider, who has committed years to uncovering the truth behind Melissa's case. Discover a touching story of his steadfast promise to Melissa's mother, a story that gives a whole new meaning to the phrase "above and beyond". Prepare to dive into the chilling details of Melissa's murder, which suggest the unthinkable; her killer might have been someone she knew. In the final chapter of our journey, we focus on the impact of LaDonna Humphrey's work in the realm of true crime. Hear about her plans for future projects, including two tantalizing new documentaries, and her optimism about the imminent issuance of an arrest warrant in the case. We'll also explore the success of the award-winning documentary "Uneven Ground: The Melissa Witt Story", a film that has given a voice to a young woman whose life was cruelly silenced. Join us for this compelling and heart-rending discussion; it's not one to be missed. TIME LINE (00:01) Unsolved Murder of Melissa Ann Witt (11:29) Jay C. Rider (19:58) Unsolved Murder and Advocacy (35:04) Melissa Witt Case and Book Series (45:32) "Uneven Ground" Documentary (51:05) Successes in True Crime Advocacy About LaDonna Humphrey LaDonna Humphrey is a writer, documentarian, investigative journalist, private investigator, Podcast host and an advocate for victims of crime. And for the past seven years, LaDonna has found herself passionately entangled in seeking justice for 19-year-old murder victim, Melissa Ann Witt. LaDonna Humphrey lives in Cave Springs, Arkansas with her husband and five of her seven children. LaDonna Humphrey Website Click Here Facebook Click Here https://www.facebook.com/whokilledmissywitt Purchase The Girl I never knew who killed Melissa Witt: Genius books <a href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/1947521810/ref=sr_1_14?keywords=the+girl+i+ne
Sun, December 03, 2023
Ep 8. The Intriguing and Infamous JonBenet Ramsey Murder:The Conclusion
Prepare for a spine-chilling ride, as we unearth the heinous mysteries surrounding the unsolved murder of young JonBenet Ramsey. Join us, your hosts Ladonna Humphrey and David McClam, as we navigate the intricacies of the relentless investigation conducted by the Boulder Police Department and the Colorado Governor. We leave no stone unturned, discussing startling theories about the identity of the murderer and presenting a chilling encounter shared by a family friend of the Ramseys. Then, brace yourself as we scrutinize eerie connections between JonBenet's case and other unresolved murders. The stakes rise as we ponder the horrifying possibility of a serial killer, lurking in the shadows of the pageant circuit, preying on young girls. Could there be two culprits involved, complicating the already baffling scenario? Join our quest for truth, as we strive to keep the pursuit of justice alive for JonBenet Ramsey, a young life tragically snuffed out, yet continuing to reverberate globally. Time Line (00:01) The JonBenet Ramsey Murder Investigation (14:30) Connections in JonBenet Ramsey's Murder Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr
Sun, November 26, 2023
Ep.7. The Intriguing and Infamous JonBenet Ramsey Murder:Intriguing Suspects, Controversial Autopsy, and a Haunting Family Mystery
In this episode, we delve into the captivating and unsolved murder case of JonBenet Ramsey. Our focus centers on two key suspects, Gary Olivia and Randall DeWitt Simons, as we explore their potential connections to this chilling crime. Join us as we critique the authorities' handling of the investigation, shedding light on the controversy surrounding the autopsy report. The text raises compelling questions about potential family involvement and delves into the theory that the perpetrator had prior access to JonBenet. We'll analyze the evidence presented and examine the need for critical thinking in dissecting this perplexing case. Throughout the episode, we explore the complexities and uncertainties surrounding the murder, leaving listeners intrigued and eager to uncover the identity of the elusive killer. Tune in to join us on this thought-provoking journey through the JonBenet Ramsey murder case. Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr
Sun, November 19, 2023
Ep.6. The Intriguing and Infamous JonBenet Ramsey Murder: Possible Suspects
In this gripping episode of "Extinguished," the hosts delve into the infamous JonBenet Ramsey murder investigation. The case, which has captivated the nation for years, continues to raise questions and intrigue. Join us as we explore various suspects and theories surrounding this tragic event. First, the hosts examine the role of JonBenet's mother, Patsy Ramsey, as a potential suspect. They shed light on the controversial aspects of the case, including the similarities between Patsy's writing and the ransom note found at the scene. Could Patsy have been involved in her daughter's untimely demise? Another suspect that comes into focus is Gary Olivia, a convicted sex offender. The hosts explore his possible connection to the crime and analyze the evidence against him. They discuss the chilling world of child beauty pageants and the potential dangers associated with them. Additionally, the podcast delves into other intriguing suspects, such as Jon Mark Carr, Bill McReynolds, and Michael Helgoth. The hosts present compelling evidence and theories surrounding these individuals, highlighting the complexities of the investigation. Throughout the episode, the host emphasizes the concerns surrounding the tampering of evidence and missing items related to the crime. These puzzling elements raise further questions about the true nature of the events that transpired on that fateful day. The Host suggests that someone close to the family may be involved, and the podcast aims to shed light on missing persons cases while honoring those who have been lost. The hosts' thorough exploration of the JonBenet Ramsey murder case encourages listeners to consider the various angles and possibilities, ultimately seeking justice and closure for the victim and her family. Tune in to this thought-provoking episode of "Extinguished" as we continue our quest for truth in unsolved mysteries. Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound M
Sun, November 12, 2023
Ep.5. The Intriguing and Infamous JonBenet Ramsey Murder
Get set for a spine-chilling journey into one of America's most infamous unsolved crimes - the puzzling murder of JonBenet Ramsey. We kick off our conversation with a deep dive into the perplexing timeline of the case. From the bone-chilling 911 call to the strange details of the ransom note, we leave no stone unturned. We grapple with the baffling decisions made by Patsy Ramsey - JonBenet's mother - that contradicted the ransom note's explicit instructions, and try to make sense of the enigmatic amount of money demanded. The plot thickens as we explore the unexpected twist after Patsy Ramsey's interview - Boulder police's revelation that the ransom note was written on a paper from the Ramsey's house. We dissect the impact of Patsy's interactions with media, under the influence of trauma, grief, and sleep deprivation. We question the premature leak of case details to the public and the Ramsey family's response to these unsettling revelations. We also delve into the controversial press conference held by the Ramsey couple and discuss its implications on their reputation. Our investigation then turns towards the eerie relocation of JonBenet's bedroom furniture to Atlanta, attempting to decode its significance. The harrowing details of JonBenet's death, as revealed in the autopsy records, are analyzed, along with the puzzling decision to stage the crime scene. We navigate through the grand jury investigation, the questioning of Burke Ramsey - JonBenet's brother - and the consequential role of media in enforcing a negative perception of the Ramsey family. Join us as we attempt to unravel the mysteries, controversies and double-dealings that continue to shroud this notorious case. Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr
Sun, November 05, 2023
Ep.4 Superbike Murders and serial killer Todd Kohlhepp
Prepare to step into the chilling world of Todd Kohlhepp, as we guide you through the twisted journey of his life and crimes. In this episode, we unmask the facade of a seemingly reformed man, revealing the cold-blooded killer hidden beneath, responsible for the horrifying Superbike Motorsport massacre and more. Starting with an exploration of Todd's tumultuous childhood, we discuss the early signs of violent tendencies and lack of empathy. The episode illuminates the path of a disturbed journey that began with animal cruelty and escalated to a heinous act of kidnapping and sexual assault at just 15. We consider the many missed opportunities for intervention, underscoring the critical need for early identification and support for individuals struggling with violent tendencies and mental health issues. As we continue our deep dive, we scrutinize Todd's manipulative tactics during his sentencing, his additional confessions, and the shockingly normal life he led between his crimes. In a haunting conclusion, we highlight the resilience of Melissa Ponder, widow to one of Todd's victims, serving as a poignant reminder of the human ability to confront trauma and find strength in the face of immense pain. Stay with us as we close this chapter and prepare to embark on a new series, focusing on unsolved murders and the importance of remembering those horrifically taken from us. Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr
Sun, October 29, 2023
Ep.3 Superbike Motorsports Murders: The trail to Todd Kohlhepp
Prepare for a chilling journey as we unravel the eerie history of the disappearance of Kayla Brown and Charles David Carver. As we tread into the chilling terrain of the unsolved Superbike Murders, we're confronted with the stark reality of the murder of Charlie Carver, and the horrifying discovery of additional bodies on the property. Katie, Charlie's sister, is our guest on this episode, shedding light on Charlie's personal side, his love for writing and their bond as siblings. This provides a much-needed human touch to the gruesome narrative. We then transition into the aftermath, the emotional fallout experienced by the families of David Carver and Kayla Brown. Dealing with such a significant public loss is a challenge that we explore, discussing various coping mechanisms employed by the grieving families. The revelation of the Superbike Murders brings an ambiguous closure to the families involved, stirring a complex mix of emotions. Finally, we go deeper into the treacherous tale of the Superbike Murders, the shocking confession that rocked the world, and its profound impact. We hear from Ladonna, the investigator who interviewed Katie - the pain, the grief, and the resilience of a sister who lost her brother to a vicious crime. This conversation is a potent reminder of the tragic consequences of these events and the indelible marks they leave on those entangled. Listen in, as we traverse this melancholic landscape of loss, love, and the resilience of the human spirit. Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr
Sun, October 22, 2023
Ep.2 Superbike Motorsports Murders: The inverstigation
Join us on a chilling journey into the heart of an unsolved mystery, the Superbike Motorsports store murders. With an eerie chill, we uncover the mind-boggling enigma of November 6th, 2003, where four innocent lives were snuffed out in cold blood. As we navigate through the eerie twists and turns of this investigation, from a potential drug dealing operation to a grievously erroneous paternity test, we are left grappling with more questions than answers. Listen closely as we scrutinize every piece of evidence, from cell phone records to flight manifests, in a relentless pursuit of truth. Hold your breath as we delve deeper into the relentless pursuit of justice for the victims. With a steely determination, investigators sift through an online customer list, a Herculean task involving thousands of potential leads. Listen as we theorize about the killer's possible motives, and ponder over the chilling possibility that the murderer could have been a disgruntled customer, his rage sparked by a transaction gone awry. And as the story unfolds, the most haunting revelation of all surfaces - the killer might have been hiding in plain sight all along. Venture with us into the shadowy corners of this case that shook an entire community to its core. Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr
Sun, October 15, 2023
Ep 1. Superbike Motorsports Murders Pt 1.
Ready for a gripping journey into the heart of a chilling crime that stunned an entire community? Brace yourselves as we unravel the haunting tale of the Superbike Motorsports Murders. In this four-part series, we shed light on the shocking events that transpired in Chesney, South Carolina, in November 2003, taking the lives of four innocent people and leaving a community reeling in horror. We follow the rollercoaster ride of Scott's widow, Melissa, whose joy of expecting their first child turned into a nightmare as accusations, DNA mix-ups, and insensitive police tactics tore her life apart. Listen closely as we dissect each heartbreaking twist and turn, from the distressing implications of a DNA test to the shocking revelation of a test mix-up, we cover every facet of this bewildering case. In the final act, be inspired by Melissa's incredible resilience as she navigates the stormy waters of adversity to rebuild her life. Despite the relentless challenges, her journey towards finding peace serves as a beacon of hope and strength. Join us in this emotional journey that serves as a tribute to Melissa and her unwavering spirit. Prepare for an emotional rollercoaster ride that leaves you on the edge of your seat, questioning everything you thought you knew about criminal investigations. Time Line (0:00:02) - The Superbike Motorsports Murders (0:07:53) - Horrific Crime and False Accusations (0:18:50) - Tragedy and Unexpected DNA Mix-Up (0:29:16) - Mixed-Up DNA and Devastating Consequences (0:40:51) - Rebuilding, Acceptance, and Finding Peace Check out our other podcast Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE JOIN US ON FACEBOOK SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr
Thu, October 12, 2023
Extinguished Trailer
Coming at you October 15, 2023. You DO NOT want to miss it!!!
loading...